Moving Exchange away from Sherweb, to ItSolutionsNow
July 19, 2008 – 03:07I’ve had it with Sherweb. If you didn’t know, I had my 3GB hosted Exchange account hosted at http://www.sherweb.com for about 5 to 6 months now and overall the overall experience was great. However … there was one thing that was bothing me… I didn’t get all my email.
Let me explain.. I set up my account (…@martijnbrant.net) and made sure the DNS settings for my domain were properly set. They were and in no time the account was up and running using Microsoft Outlook 2007 and Windows Mobile 6.0 (Push email). All was great and all my email was being delivered to my inbox.
Half a day later .. I got a (what the server thought to be) spam message and I didn’t recieve it. At the end of the day, the server had send me a anti-spam reporting showing I had one message waiting for me at the webinterface for anti-spam. Turns out .. Sherweb was using a product called Barracuda Spam Firewall. It sat between my email and my inbox.. filtering emails and quarantining them in the webinterface. I found this annoying and I quickly turned it off (making it tag spam instead..).
All was fine again .. untill I was planning my trip to Florida. I had the hotel I was going to be staying in (which was great, Choicehotels are awesome value) on the phone and manager who booked my stay said he sended the confirmation of my hotel reservation to my mb.net email account. One hour later, I still hadn’t recieved it. I rang them up and had them send it to my Hotmail Windows Live Mail account. Sure .. 2 secs later I had recieved the email. “That’s strange huh?”
I dismissed the problem and went on my trip to Florida. After I got back .. I was curious as to how this could have happened. I tried to forward the stored email from my WLM account to my Sherweb account. Never recieved it. Surprised by this, I rang Sherweb. After going trough the usual Level-1-support stuff, I got through to Level 2. The guy was friendly enough and tracked down the email. “Ah I see .. blocked”. Ok sure, I replied .. why is it blocked and why can’t I see that?
“Well sir the Barracuda filtering system uses 3rd party blacklists in order to tag spam. Messages containing keywords from that list will be deleted”. Wait what? You deleted my email?!?! “Yes sir, for your protection”. Erhmm Ok .. On what word was it blocked? “Lemme just see here … ah .. choicehotels.com sir”. Wait what? As for as I understand it, Choicehotels is a pretty large organisation with 1000s of hotels all over the USA. “Yeah the word is blocked sir”.
It turned out I couldn’t see what emails were being blocked or for what reason. I had no idea on how much emails (read: business) I had lost over this. I asked Sherweb “What should I do with my important email? Just use my Windows Live Mail for all the important bits?”. He replied “Err yeah you could do that…”. “- Why am I paying you then?” … “Well sir, you could still use your Sherweb account for all personal stuff”. What?!?! Sure buddy .. I’ll just use my 100$ email account for personal stuff… I have WLM for that..
So .. as of today I’m migrating over to http://www.exchangemailhosting.com. I rang them up and told them/asked them about my Sherweb problems and if they had similar systems. They chuckled and replied “No sir, we believe in NOT trowing email away”. Hehe.
I hope exchangemailhosting.com will be better. We’ll see. Just about done with the DNS. Wait a couple of more days and then cancel my Sherweb service. They told me they’ll refund my pre-paid 3 month period. So have to hand it to them .. that’s great. Overall Sherweb is great if it wasn’t for their email-eating practice.
13 Responses to “Moving Exchange away from Sherweb, to ItSolutionsNow”
How are you finding exchangemailhosting.com as a provider? They are on a list of possibles for our company mail migration, but my big reservation is that I can’t find out much about them - apart from the fact that they have flooded the internet with press releases. Any feedback would be gratefully received.
By James Craig on Jul 31, 2008
Hey James,
So far so good! Setup and migration was easier then any other party (aside from the fact they don’t have a step-by-step setup guide for those who are new to hosted (exchange) email…
Their control panel rocks .. really great and 10x faster then that P.O.S. panel Sherweb gives you. Very flexible!
They are a little bit more expensive but still in the “dead-cheap” zone. I rang them up a couple of times and had great support over the phone!
So far I’m giving this host a big fat 10 / A+!
By Martijn Brant on Aug 2, 2008
Martijn, thank you for taking the time to let me know your opinions - I think there is a good chance that they will come out on top of a list of possibles. I wanted to use Intermedia, but the cost is a little prohibitive. All the best, James.
By James Craig on Aug 4, 2008
Intermedia looks OK however it’s only worth looking at when hosting 3+ mailboxes. As I only needed one for my business, Sherweb and ITSolutionsNow were a better choice for me.
Oh btw .. Their ROI calculator is way off as it uses retail prices to calculate your savings (compared to Volume Licensing)
By Martijn Brant on Aug 4, 2008
Martijn,
You possible saved me from making a big mistake. I’ve been using mail2web.com for the last couple of weeks. Thinking of moving to Sherweb, they were one of the hosts that allowed me to forward my mail and not change DNS. But after hearing your woes with email filtering, I’m looking elsewhere.
By Jordan on Aug 21, 2008
You need trackbacks!
By Jordan on Aug 21, 2008
On my side I’ve been with Sherweb for close to a year now. No problem what-so-ever even with their spam filter. When the filter isn’t sure it send it in a quarantine report and I’m able to tell the system to let it go through or not.
So, I haven’t lost 1 e-mail and almost no spam at all.
very please with the service compared to what I had before
By Stan Marx on Sep 15, 2008
How r u getting on as I am thinking of moving too.
By JB on Sep 26, 2008
I started off using 1and1 exchange server a couple of years ago, the price was good. After a few months I started experiencing downtime so I moved to Mail2Web. The service there was pretty good, then they decided to raise the price. I then moved to Sherweb, the service was good but once again, downtime and spam problems. Then I moved to ITSolutionsNow towards the beginning of this year and they have been outstanding. You cannot beat the price and I have not found another service that offers unlimited exchange!
By Donnie on Nov 18, 2008
Hmm, just tried a message with choicehotels and it went very well.. I have no complaints with Sherweb to date. Fine service Excellent support, phone or email.
By Phil on Apr 14, 2009
Hello,
Are you already happy with ITSolutionsNow ?
I am interesting to go with ItsolutionsNow but can’t find any review except your blog.
By Chris on Nov 23, 2009
I am still very pleased with ITSolutionsNow and am still using their service every day. Hardly any downtime (as far as I notice) and speeds are OK (seeing I’m from Europe and the servers are in the US, I forgive the higher ping).
By Martijn on Nov 23, 2009
Thanks for your answer.
I am in europe too and interesting by Itsolutionsnow because price is interesting for unlimeted mailbox size.
I haven’t see any system status about service and this is very difficult to know if there is donwtime …
Are you happy with forefront antispam ?
Because my previous test with forefront with other provider has been not very good ?
I have test by the past sherweb too but don’t like barracuda anti-spam.
By Chris on Nov 23, 2009